Audiophile
Speakers
| Want
to build 'audiophile speakers' that outperform the most expensive
commercial loudspeakers out there?
Is
this really possible? Can I really do this? In one word
- Yes!
I
was doubtful, too when I was looking for this type of kit
because we usually tend to believe the hype in magazines
and media so much. It took me a while to grasp why especially
DIY audiophile speakers can potentially sound better than
commercial ones and cost less, too.
|
|
First
of all, audiophile retail loudspeakers are not produced in large
quantities because the demand is generally lower. This requires
higher markups on the premium parts used to make these loudspeakers.
To justify higher prices, manufacturers wrap the drivers in expensive,
stylish cabinets. And we haven't yet considered cost of labour
which doesn't come cheap either.
So
this explains why most reference loudspeakers have 5-digit price-tags...Ouch!
Being
hobbyists, we don't need to care about markets, trends or cover
manufacturing costs. What made me hooked on DIY audiophile speakers
is the fact that you can buy the exactly same drivers and parts
used in high-end loudspeakers directly from the manufacturer! And
the kits I mention here were engineered by renowned specialist
such as Sigfried Linkwitz, Joe D'appolito or Manfred Zoller. It's
not just like buying factory-direct but rather like buying
directly from the developer.
In
other words, you could contact the guy who developed your loudspeakers
and ask for help should you ever run into problems.
I have yet to see a commercial loudspeaker with this level of support.
So
if your budget can stretch, say $1200 to $4000 a pair for an audiophile
speaker kit, you can definitely build that no-compromise true reference
speaker you've always been dreaming about. I assume you already
have clear sonic preferences (e.g. fast, deep bass or high resolution)
hence I recommend you carefully audition several speaker kits before
spending that kind of money. Take your time, bring your favorite
music and please resist that frantic urge to spend!
I
have experienced that it can be quite challenging to sell expensive
DIY speakers second hand for a good price just because you weren't
satisfied with their sonics. And you shouldn't skimp on the cabinet
build quality and finish of your speakers either. After all you're
building reference speakers, aren't you?
Ask
your kit dealer about return-policies, warranties and get in touch
with others who have built the same speaker kit. You want to be
sure your loudspeaker investment is going to last at least a couple
of years.
Ok,
let's find your dream audiophile speaker kit now! Before we continue,
I want to summarize our requirements...
What
to look for in an Audiophile Speaker?
You basically
want a loudspeaker that masters one or a few areas of audio reproduction
with highest perfection and without compromises:
Undistorted,
lifelike reproduction of voices and musical instruments- Reveals
even tiny details in your recordings- Dynamic, effortless playback
and precise bass
Kit
Price Ranges
Audiophile
speaker kits matching these requirements are available in various designsand
price ranges from approximately $1200 up to about $4000. Often severalkit
upgrades are available such as better (and thus pricier) crossover
components.
What
Does a Kit Contain?
In this
price category expect only premium drivers and crossover components.Many
speaker kits contain expensive, top-of-the-line drivers from Seas Excel
or Peerlessor sophisticated ribbon tweeter constructions. Additionally,
more exotic crossover parts with better precision or elitist cables
for internal speaker wiring are included.Cabinets are not included
but you can build one according to the construction planor have someone
build it for you at reasonable
cost. It's not at all difficult.
Audiophile
Speaker Kit Recommendations:
My list
of recommended kits is not nearly complete. It's all based on personal
listening experiences and positive reviews of other customers.
Zoller
Ultimate Solution (from $4000/pair)If
you love the airiness of electrostatic speakers with a fluid
midrangeand crystal-clear treble plus great bass, Manfred
Zoller's Ultimate Solution speaker kit should be on your
hotlist. While this is still an insiders' tip, several audiophiles
are ranking this speaker among the absolute best loudspeakers
on this planetregardless of price. Two paper midrange woofers
frame a sophisticated ribbon tweeter in a D'Appolito arrangement.
You can use this speaker in fullrange stereoor home theater
applications. Add an additional subwoofer for very large
rooms or more slam although I doubt that you're going to
need one for normal playback levels.I love the fact that
this speaker was designed with time-pase coherency perfection
in mind. Thus each driver is housed in its own cabinet, completely
adjustable on the vertical angle and decoupled from vibrations.
Active and passive crossover versions are available.Although
Manfred's Kit is more expensive, I bet it'll be difficult
to find a commercial loudspeaker that comes close to its
performance.
Zoller
Temptation Reloaded (from $2200/pair)I
personally built and own this loudspeaker so I can tell you
a lot about its sonic properties.Manfred's Temptation Reloaded
is basically a scaled-down version of his Ultimate Solution
kit. It's suitable for smaller rooms (<20m2). I couldn't
afford the Ultimate Solution kit and wanted an audiophile
speaker that performs great in smaller rooms. This loudspeaker
kit comeswith a smaller ribbon tweeter of similar quality
and the same paper-midrange woofer that's being usedin the
Ultimate Solution project, however it only employs a single
midrange driver per speaker.Two 7 inch woofers per speaker
reproduce the bass. Like its bigger brother, the Temptationrelies
on Manfred's "stacked cabinet" philosophy. The woofers are
housed in a bass-reflex cabinet while midrange driver and
tweeter share a single cabinet. It looks like a small monitor
or satellite speaker positioned on top of the woofer cabinet.
I use spikes to decouple both cabinets. I was surprised how
easy it is to build this cabinet - even for a novice woodworker
like me.As for the sound...wow. I still get goosebumps every
time they start singing. The loudspeakers just seem to disappear
and let me enjoy what I'd call the best midrange and treble
I have ever heard. I even use them for 2-channel home theater.
My wife is still shocked when our telephone suddenly ringsand
it actually turns out to be on the recording :) I have probably
listened to almost every commercial high-end loudspeaker
out there but find the Temptation Reloaded a steal for their
asking price. I would definitely build them again. I should
also note that they are extremely frugal when it comes to
power consumption. I once hooked them up to a 20W tube amplifier
and they still sound terrific.
Selah
Audio Alexandrite/XT8 line
array speaker kits (from $3850/pair)If you fancy big tower
speakers for larger listening rooms and love lifelike dynamics,why
not give Rick Craig's Alexandrite or XT8 a listen? He combines
a whopping eight ribbon tweeters and 7 inch Seas Excel midrange
woofers in a truly impressive line array. And their high sensitivity
allows them to be driven by tube amps, too. Line array speakers
provide a highly consistent sound field allowing a performance
comparable to a live event whereas other speakers often only
sound good when sitting within their "sweet spot" area. I would
say it's simply a matter of taste because line arrays definitely
sound different.
Linkwitz
Orion (from $1500/pair) Developed by
speaker-designer Sigfried Linkwitz (yes, he's the guy who
co-developed the famous Linkwitz-Reilly crossover), the Orion
is a unique open-baffle 3-way speaker.Open-baffle means the
backside of the cabinet is open (except for the woofers)
and rearwall reflections are desired. The Orion is operated
by an active crossover so you are going to need one power
amplifier per driver. Because there are eight drivers altogether,
I recommend either getting a good 8-channel amplifier or
buying additional amplifiers (in case you already have one
or two that can be reused for this project). You may also
get away cheaper by building a few LM3886 "Gainclones" or
looking for second-hand amplifiers. Just make sure the voltage
gain of your amplifiers is identical. Orion speakers combine
Seas' prestigious Millenium dome tweeters with a neodymium
based magnet system and an 8" Seas midrange woofer. Two 10" Peerless
woofers per speaker provide the necessary bass slam.Orion
speakers are not only extremely revealing, airy and punchy
- they also make a great home theater frontend! I love this
kit because the active crossover allows experimenting with
different amplifiers. You can virtually customize this speaker
to your taste. And Sigfried Linkwitz lets you choose how
much you actually want to do yourself. Completely assembled
crossovers and even complete Orion speakers are available.
Any skill level is covered so you should be able to successfully
build your own reference audiophile speaker.
Seas
Thor (from
$1075/pair)This speaker kit combines the cream of the crop
both in engineering and driver quality. It's intended as
a showcase project for Seas showing the sonic potential of
their top-of-the line Millenium drivers when properly implemented.
Dr. Joseph D'Appolito has personally developed this speaker
for Seas. It's a transmissionline construction (a folded
air-duct inside the loudspeaker is used to compound low frequencies
as opposed to bassreflex) employing two Seas W18E001 woofers
and one renowned Millennium tweeter per speaker in a D'Appolito
configuration.This loudspeaker kit results in a speaker with
great overall performance and you can even buy beautiful
pre-built cabinets for them. It's a good choice if you want
to build a reference speaker with little time investment
because so many aspects can be bought as "plug-and-play" components.

|